Chocolate Heart Cookies

Chocolate Heart Cookies

Sharing is caring!

Valentine’s Day is fast approaching. What better way to show our family and friends, how much they are loved and appreciated by baking a big batch of these Chocolate Heart Cookies.

Chocolate Heart Cookies
Imagine the joy and surprise on your loved one’s faces as you hand around these Chocolate Heart Cookies.

Although it is nice to take one day out of the year, such as Valentine’s Day, to let people know we love them, I think it is far more important to tell those we love every day. To ‘love’ is a verb, a doing word and so the act of loving people, should be part of our daily lives.

I love baking for my loved ones and seeing their faces as they bite into something delicious, that has been made by me, just for them. It shows them that they are important to me and loved very much.

Chocolate Heart Cookies
Chocolate Heart a Cookies packaged up ready for collection.

These Chocolate Heart Cookies can be made for a fraction of the cost of buying Valentine’s Day gifts and they are so personal. When they are made you make them with love. There is also this added bonus, you can make these all year round and believe me, these cookies are so utterly delicious, your loved ones will keep coming back for more!!

The reason for the outstandingly, melt in the mouth flavour of these cookies, is, because they contain cream cheese.

Didn’t see that one coming – hey? 😉

Yep, good old Philly makes a real difference to the soft, almost, truffle like, texture of the cookies and they taste amazing too!

Chocolate Heart Cookies
Chocolate Heart Cookies– who will you share these with?

If you are going to make these cookies, it’s worth using a good quality cocoa powder, as that directly affects the chocolate flavour of these hearts. You only use 50g per batch, so it works out pretty cost effective, overall. Food Thoughts Cocoa is a great quality fair trade, organic cocoa powder.

I used a fluted heart cutter and was happily surprised that each cookie kept the definition during baking.

Chocolate Heart Cookies
These Chocolate Heart Cookies look so pretty, packaged up and tied with ribbon.

Recipe: Makes 20-30 Chocolate Heart Cookies, depending on cutter size.

150g/5oz Soft Light Brown Sugar

100g/4oz Unsalted Butter at room temp.

100g/4oz Full Fat Soft Cheese – I used Philadelphia

1/4tsp Salt

1 Large Egg Yolk

1/2tsp Vanilla Bean Paste – alternatively 1tsp Vanilla Extract

50g/2oz Cocoa Powder

225g/8oz Plain White Flour – plus extra for dusting the worktop

100g/4oz White Chocolate


  • Add the softened cream cheese, butter, salt and sugar to a large bowl.
  • Whisk together until fully combined.
  • Now add the egg yolk, vanilla and whisk in.
  • Sift the flour and cocoa into the bowl.
  • Mix together until uniform in colour and texture.
  • Wipe the work surface with a clean, damp cloth.
  • Lay cling film over the damp worktop, it will stick and not move.
  • Place the cookie dough onto the cling film, form into a disc a wrap tightly.
  • Place the wrapped cookie dough into the fridge to chill for one hour.

When you are ready to bake the Chocolate Heart Cookies preheat the oven to 170C/155C fan.

  • Line 2-3 large baking trays with baking parchment.
Chocolate Heart Cookies
Remove the dough from the fridge.
  • If the cookie dough has been in the fridge for more than a few hours (I made the dough on Sunday and baked on Monday), remove and leave to warm slightly for 30 minutes. This will prevent the dough from cracking.
  • Divide the dough in two and wrap one half in the cling film.
  • Lightly dust the worktop with flour.
  • Roll the dough out to approx 1/4 inch thickness (6mm).
  • Ensure you are constantly moving the dough and lightly dusting the worktop with flour – as this dough can get quite sticky.
Chocolate Heart Cookies
Don’t worry about a very light dusting of flour on top of the dough.
  • Using a 2 inch (10cm) heart cutter, cut out the cookies.
  • Re-rolling the cookie dough so you can get the maximum number of cookies from it.
  • Roll the second half of cookie dough and continue as before.
  • I cut out 27 cookies.
Chocolate Heart Cookies
Place the cut out cookies onto the baking tray.
  • Place the baking trays into the oven and bake for exactly 10 minutes.
  • The cookies will have a slightly matt appearance when baked.
  • Once baked remove the trays from the oven and allow the cookies to cool on the tray.

Decorating the Chocolate Heart Cookies.

Chocolate Heart Cookies
When the cookies are completely cooled move them and the baking parchment to the worktop.
  • Lay your cookies out in a uniform manner. This will make it easier to pipe the melted chocolate on.
  • Into a heatproof and microwaveable bowl add the chopped up white chocolate.
  • Heat on 20 second bursts – remembering that white chocolate keeps its shape when melted.
  • Stir after ever 20 seconds and remove just before all the white chocolate has completely melted.
  • Continue stirring until all the chocolate has melted.
  • Spoon the warm, melted chocolate into a disposable piping bag – alternatively, using a fork you can drizzle the chocolate over the cookies.
  • Snip the very end off of the piping bag so that there is only a small hole.
  • Pipe a squiggle pattern over the heart cookies, I found it easier to pipe them in vertical lines without stopping, just lift the bag tip upwards, after the last heart in each line is drizzled.
Chocolate Heart Cookies
Pipe squiggles of white chocolate across the hearts.
  • Allow to cool completely. This can take a little while and during hotter weather (it is Winter here now) they may need to go into the fridge to set completely.
Chocolate Heart Cookies
Chocolate Heart Cookies ready to be shared with your loved ones.

These are the perfect ‘I Love You’ gift anytime of the year!

Do you like to bake as a way of expressing love?

If you enjoyed making these Chocolate Heart Cookies, then you might like to try this:

Chocolate Heart Cake

Cookies Chocolate Heart Cake
Chocolate Heart Cake

Super Light Scones just cut them out with a heart cutter!

Cookies Super Light Scones
Super Light Scones

I hope that you know you are loved, see Important Stuff.

Sammie x

Follow Us

Published by



Hi, I'm Sammie and I’m passionate about creating tasty recipes that you can make at home. Let me help you turn fear into fun with step by step instructions for making delicious feasts that you are proud to share.

8 thoughts on “Chocolate Heart Cookies”

  1. How very cute are these adorable little cookies??? Perfect for Valentines Day! Besides that, they look so easy to make too! Thanks Sammie for a perfect recipe right in time! I might tackle these over the weekend!

  2. I adore fluted cookie cutters! It’s such an easy way of making a simple shape extra fancy. These cookies look delicious and I’m definitely going to try my hand at making them. I think my little nieces and nephews will gobble them up! Thanks Sammie!

    1. Ah they will love whatever you bake for them, I saw the gorgeous cookie basket for Christmas. I am really pleased with these cutters from Wilton, one side is fluted and the other straight. Definitely a good buy. Thanks for you lovely comments. Sammie x

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *